Toymakers Ignore Science
Since I was 7 years old I’ve ridden horses and for the last 9 years been the proud owner of my very own, so a knowledge of the gaits of horses and other four-legged animals is pretty much second nature to me now, so I was interested in this article on Science Daily which discusses the results of a new study that shows a rather alarming number of anatomists, taxidermists and, perhaps less surprisingly, toymakers do not get the walking gait of horses and other animals such as dogs correct.
The study which was published in Current Biology on 27th January, was carried out by Hungarian researchers following on from previous research which had discovered that horses’ limbs were often wrongly illustrated. The scientists decided to see if such errors also applied to museums, veterinary books and toy shops by collecting hundreds of walking portrayals and seeing if the limbs were correctly positioned.
With the correct walking behaviour of quadruped animals described and published over 120 years ago by the pioneer Eadweard Muybridge in the 1880s, the researchers were rather alarmed to discover that over 50% of their samples showed errors:
We found that almost half of the depictions are wrong. This high error rate in walking illustrations in natural history museums and veterinary anatomy books is particularly unexpected in a time where high-speed cameras and the internet offer ideal possibilities to obtain reliable quantitative information about tetrapod walking.
[Horváth, G. et al, "Erroneous quadruped walking depictions in natural history museum", Current Biology 2009]
The method of walking is virtually universal between all four-legged animals since it provides maximum stability. Small differences only in the exact timing of the steps exist between animals. All four-legged animals step first with their left hindleg, then their left foreleg before finally their right hindleg and lastly their right foreleg. When walking fairly slowly, the dog or horse’s body is supported by 3 of it’s feet – effectively forming a triangle. They are more stable if their centre of mass is closer to the centre of the triangles 3 points. If children’s toys followed the biomechanics more closely, it would be likely that they would fall over less. However, ignoring this practicality, it is rather more imperative that natural history museums and anatomical textbooks follow the scientific correctness more rigorously!
Interestingly, despite the carelessness of some toymakers, Horváth did observe that Holloywood movies, such as Lord of the Rings, generally do a more accurate job of depicting walking animals!
Anyone who would like to read a little more about the biomechanics should read the article on Discover Magazine’s website called “The Flesh of Physics” which has some great graphical illustrations and also some slow-motion video clips of horses galloping allowing their footfall to be accurately observed (NB. The footfall during galloping is obviously not the same as when walking despite them both being a four-beat movement)